“Some women choose to follow men, and some women choose to follow their dreams. If you’re wondering which way to go, remember that your career will never wake up and tell you that it doesn’t love you anymore.”
— Lady Gaga
As much as I respect and admire Lady Gaga, this is some of the worst advice I’ve ever heard, because it’s incredibly misleading.
First of all, it’s probably just as easy to lose your career as it is to lose your partner. Here are a few examples:
- a pro football player permanently injures his leg
- a writer gets depressed and loses her creativity
- a doctor loses a malpractice suit and is no longer allowed to practice medicine
- a politician becomes disenchanted with the system in which she works
- an artist starts losing his vision
- a lawyer at a prestigious firm gets burned out
And so on.
Furthermore, if it were the case that everyone who puts aside relationships for the sake of their careers ends up doing what they love most and getting paid millions for it like Lady Gaga, perhaps her advice would hold up. But for most of today’s young people, who sacrifice love and dating for the sake of working 60-hour weeks and making comparatively little money, the choice isn’t really such an obvious one.
Second, it’s exactly this mentality that prevents people from making the sort of commitment that prevents relationships from breaking down. I’m not saying all relationships (and marriages) are made to last, but putting your career first every time is one way to make sure they don’t. I know students here who will break off perfectly good relationships because 1) they can’t deal with spending one summer apart, and 2) they’re so obsessed with getting the perfect summer internship that they don’t even try to end up in the same city together. Of course, one could argue that college relationships don’t matter much (though I’d never argue that, personally), but people keep acting like this long after graduation. For instance, by doing as Lady Gaga recommends and choosing careers over relationships.
I feel like sentiments like this one are an overblown response to the old-fashioned way of looking things, which was that a woman should sacrifice all of her ambitions for the sake of a marriage. Obviously, I disagree with that completely, but I feel like asking women to sacrifice all of their relationships for the sake of their ambitions is just as one-sided and faulty way of looking at things. Statements like this one construct these two aspects of adult life as diametrically opposed when they really aren’t. Plenty of women manage to have fulfilling careers and loving marriages. It just takes a bit of work, that’s all.
The truth is that nothing in your life is ever going to be perfect, all the time. When your relationships aren’t going well, an interesting and meaningful career can help you get through it. But what about when your career isn’t going well?
In short, yes, balancing love and work is difficult. That doesn’t mean we should just opt out of that balance altogether and pick one over the other. It’s unfortunate that people like Lady Gaga, whom many young women consider a role model, has made it sound like we need to abandon one of these important things for the sake of the other.
I love this! Striking a balance seems like the only logical choice to me and yet so many people are happy to flush a relationship if the career doesn’t follow. I think Gaga is hearkening back to the days of angry girl bands, and that’s fun in it’s own way. But she doesn’t have to totally trounce on romance on the way.
Pingback: Why I Criticize Liberals and Not Conservatives « Brute Reason
“I’m not saying all relationships (and marriages) are made to last, but putting your career first every time is one way to make sure they don’t.” — I agree with this.
“I know students here who will break off perfectly good relationships because 1) they can’t deal with spending one summer apart, and 2) they’re so obsessed with getting the perfect summer internship that they don’t even try to end up in the same city together.” — IMO if they can’t spend one summer apart, it’s a good thing they broke up because they don’t love each other that much anyway.
I’d agree with Lady Gaga when it comes to flings and casual dating. I know far too many girls who have ignored their goals to follow guys, only to end up brokenhearted or pregnant or jobless or all of the above. For sure, girls shouldn’t ignore their studies or career for a guy if they’re not sure that it will work out, or if they’re not sure they even want it to work out. But once a couple is serious and committed, then I would say it’s time to balance and compromise (if necessary) work and love.